Cross-border transfers and data localization

Data crosses borders through support tools, analytics, cloud regions and a developer on another continent, far more often than through a deliberate decision. The review starts with those flows, not with the contract template.

The short version

A cross-border transfer review identifies where personal data leaves the country or region it was collected in, which legal mechanism each transfer relies on, and where a law requires data to stay put. It builds on the flows found by data mapping, and it is worked alongside your counsel, who decides what the law requires of you.

Specialists in privacy law, including the EU and UK GDPR, join the engagements where a regime needs them.

Choosing the mechanism

The questions run in a fixed order, and the first answer usually decides the rest: an adequacy decision for the destination, then clauses or the UK agreement with an assessment where there is none, and in either case a check for any law that requires the data to stay in-country.

How the mechanism for a transfer is chosen A decision starting from where the data goes. If the destination has an adequacy decision, the transfer can rely on it. If it does not, use standard contractual clauses, or the UK agreement or addendum, with a transfer impact assessment. If a law requires the data to stay in the country, store it there first and then assess what may leave. Where does the personal data go? The destination has an adequacydecision Rely on it, and record that youdo No adequacy decision Clauses or UK agreement, plus anassessment A law requires the data to stayin-country Store it there first; assesswhat may leave
The tree is a way of asking the questions; the answers are for counsel.

Adequacy decisions are made by the European Commission and listed on its adequacy decisions page; check the current list rather than a summary of it.

EU, UK and the clauses

The EU standard contractual clauses are the set of model clauses adopted by Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2021/914 of 4 June 2021, and they ask the parties to assess whether the destination country’s law and practice allow the clauses to be followed. The decision is published on EUR-Lex.

For transfers from the UK, the ICO’s International Data Transfer Agreement and the Addendum to the EU clauses have been in force since 21 March 2022. The ICO explains both on its guidance page.

The assessment of the destination’s law, often called a transfer impact assessment, is the part most organizations skip. We draft it from the transfer facts and hand it to your counsel for the legal conclusions.

Localization regimes, at a high level

Some laws require personal data to be stored in the country as well as restricting transfers out; China’s Personal Information Protection Law, for example, requires critical information infrastructure operators, and handlers processing personal information in volumes set by the national cyberspace authority, to store personal information collected and produced in China within China (Article 40). Such rules are amended often, so the current text is checked at the start of each engagement.

China’s Personal Information Protection Law also sets several routes for transfers abroad, including a security assessment and a standard contract, and India’s Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 is a further regime that may apply. An English translation of the Chinese law is held by DigiChina.

These laws are amended often, so we do not summarize obligations here. Where a regime applies, the engagement works from its current official text and your counsel’s reading of it. Pages by region are reached from the regions page; for Canada see Canadian data residency for SaaS.

What you get

  • A transfer register. Each flow, its destination, the vendor involved and the mechanism relied on.
  • Transfer impact assessments drafted for the flows that need one.
  • A localization view. Which systems hold data a localization law covers, and where that data physically sits.
  • A fix list. Contract gaps, hosting changes and vendor questions, with owners.

Vendor contract points are in privacy risk register and vendor management.

Under EU law

The GDPR allows a transfer of personal data to a third country only if the conditions in its Chapter V are met by the controller and the processor, including for onward transfers (Article 44). The chapter provides for a transfer on the basis of a Commission adequacy decision (Article 45), subject to appropriate safeguards where there is none (Article 46), or, in specific situations, under the derogations in Article 49. The record of processing must identify each transfer (Article 30(1)(e)), and the Regulation’s higher fine ceiling covers infringements of the transfer rules (Article 83(5)). The text is on EUR-Lex; the transfer inventory we build is described on the GDPR programme page, and which route fits a given transfer is a question for your counsel.

How the work is bounded

The scope is agreed in writing before work starts, and the engagement is quoted in writing with it.

SecHB does not issue certifications, attestations or audit opinions: those come from accredited certification bodies, CPA firms and QSAs. The work here is what an organization does to be ready for them.

Nothing here is legal advice. Where a question turns on the law, the work is done alongside the client’s counsel, not instead of them.

Questions we are asked

What is a cross-border transfer review?

A cross-border transfer review identifies where personal data leaves the country or region it was collected in, which legal mechanism each transfer relies on, and where a law requires data to stay put.

What are the EU standard contractual clauses?

The EU standard contractual clauses are the set of model clauses adopted by Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2021/914 of 4 June 2021, and they ask the parties to assess whether the destination country’s law and practice allow the clauses to be followed.

What replaces the clauses for transfers from the UK?

For transfers from the UK, the ICO’s International Data Transfer Agreement and the Addendum to the EU clauses have been in force since 21 March 2022.

What is data localization?

Some laws require personal data to be stored in the country as well as restricting transfers out; China’s Personal Information Protection Law, for example, requires critical information infrastructure operators, and handlers processing personal information in volumes set by the national cyberspace authority, to store personal information collected and produced in China within China (Article 40).

What about China and India?

China’s Personal Information Protection Law also sets several routes for transfers abroad, including a security assessment and a standard contract, and India’s Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 is a further regime that may apply.

Tell us where the data goes

Background reading: cross-border transfers in 2026. List the vendors, hosting regions and countries involved, and which laws you think apply. The reply says what a review would cover. See also all privacy services.

Discuss a scope