Website consent and cookie review

The notice says one thing and the network tab says another. Most consent problems are not in the wording; they are in a tag added by marketing last spring that nobody connected to the banner.

The short version

A website consent and cookie review compares what a site says it does, in its banner and notices, with what it actually does when a visitor loads a page, declines, or sends an opt-out signal. The result is a list of what loads, when, for whom, and what needs to change.

A banner is only as good as what happens behind it: a common failure is a declined choice that is recorded while the trackers still fire.

What the review looks at

Trackers against the banner

Every cookie, pixel, script and request is recorded in three states: on first load, after the visitor declines, and after the visitor accepts. Anything that loads in the first two states without a basis is a finding.

Consent signals

Google consent mode lets a site pass the visitor’s choice to Google tags through four consent types: ad_storage, analytics_storage, ad_user_data and ad_personalization. See Google’s consent mode documentation. The review checks that the values the tags receive match the choice the visitor made.

Opt-out signals

Global Privacy Control is a browser or extension setting that signals a visitor’s privacy choice to websites, and California’s regulations require businesses to treat a qualifying opt-out preference signal as a valid opt-out request. The signal is described at globalprivacycontrol.org, and California’s rules are on the California Privacy Protection Agency site. The review tests whether the site detects the signal and acts on it.

Forms, embeds and apps

Contact forms, chat widgets, video embeds, tag managers and mobile SDKs, which often send data the banner never mentions.

How a consent signal should travel

At each page load the review verifies four steps in order: the page loads with nothing optional running, the visitor’s banner choice or opt-out signal is read, the consent state is set and passed to the tags, and the tags then fire or wait according to that state.

How a consent choice should reach the tags Four steps in order: the page loads, the banner or an opt-out signal is read, the consent state is set, and tags fire or are held according to that state. 1 The page loads Nothing optional runs yet. 2 The choice is read Banner choice or opt-out signal. 3 The state is set Passed to tags, for example by consentmode. 4 Tags fire or wait According to that state.
A failure at any step shows up as a tracker that loads regardless.

The findings register records which step failed for each tracker, so the fix goes to the right owner.

What you get

  • A tracker inventory with its state before consent, after refusal and after acceptance.
  • Findings for each mismatch with the banner or the privacy notice, in plain language, with evidence.
  • A fix list split between tag-manager changes, banner configuration and engineering work.
  • Notice corrections so the cookie and privacy notices describe what the site really does; wording that is a legal question goes to your counsel.

The inventory also feeds the records of processing, and refusals and opt-outs connect to request operations. Choosing a consent platform is covered in privacy tool selection.

Who it is for

Organizations with advertising or analytics on their sites, software companies with a marketing site and an application, and anyone who has changed banner vendor or tag manager and not retested.

Under US law

California requires businesses to honor opt-out preference signals, and the California Privacy Protection Agency gives the Global Privacy Control as an example (CPPA FAQ). In a review, that means testing in a real browser, with the signal switched on, that the site’s tags and sharing actually change. Other states’ rules differ and are listed on US state privacy law readiness.

Under EU law

The ePrivacy Directive (2002/58/EC), Article 5(3), allows storing information on a user’s device, or reading information already stored there, only on condition that the user has given consent after clear and comprehensive information about the purposes. It does not prevent technical storage or access for the sole purpose of carrying out a transmission, or that is strictly necessary for a service the user explicitly requested. In a review we test, in a real browser before any choice is made, what the site stores and reads, and sort each tag into those two groups for your counsel. The GDPR’s own rules are on the GDPR programme page.

How the work is bounded

The scope is agreed in writing before work starts, and the engagement is quoted in writing with it.

SecHB does not issue certifications, attestations or audit opinions: those come from accredited certification bodies, CPA firms and QSAs. The work here is what an organization does to be ready for them.

Nothing here is legal advice. Where a question turns on the law, the work is done alongside the client’s counsel, not instead of them.

Questions we are asked

What does a website consent and cookie review cover?

A website consent and cookie review compares what a site says it does, in its banner and notices, with what it actually does when a visitor loads a page, declines, or sends an opt-out signal.

Is a cookie banner enough?

A banner is only as good as what happens behind it: a common failure is a declined choice that is recorded while the trackers still fire.

What is Google consent mode?

Google consent mode lets a site pass the visitor’s choice to Google tags through four consent types: ad_storage, analytics_storage, ad_user_data and ad_personalization.

What is Global Privacy Control?

Global Privacy Control is a browser or extension setting that signals a visitor’s privacy choice to websites, and California’s regulations require businesses to treat a qualifying opt-out preference signal as a valid opt-out request.

Send the address and the tools you use

Background reading: testing what your consent banner really does. Give the site addresses and the analytics, advertising and banner tools in use. The reply says what a review would cover. See also all privacy services.

Discuss a scope