Preparing for a regulator inquiry

The first days after a regulator’s letter Four steps in order: route the letter to counsel and an owner, hold the relevant records, work out where the answers are, then meet staff on scope and timing. 1 Route to counsel and an owner The same day. 2 Hold the relevant records Stop routine deletion. 3 Find where the answers are Systems, people, vendors. 4 Meet staff on scope and timing Counsel leads.
Counsel leads; we prepare the records and the search.

A regulator’s letter is a deadline with a subject. The organizations that answer it well are the ones that knew, before it came, who would open it and where the records are.

The short version

Preparing for a regulator inquiry is making sure that, when a letter or a demand arrives, the organization can find who owns it, what it asks for and which records answer it, within the time it gives.

We do not represent you before a regulator and we do not give legal advice; your counsel handles the regulator, and we prepare the systems, records and people they will draw on.

Under US law

A civil investigative demand from the US Federal Trade Commission is a legally enforceable demand, and the FTC says recipients should respond promptly and fully and meet and confer with its staff about scope and deadlines. The FTC’s own page on civil investigative demands says so, and the rule is 16 CFR 2.7.

Under the FTC’s rules a recipient must meet and confer with Commission staff within 14 days after receiving the process or before the deadline for filing a petition to quash, whichever is first. A demand may call for documents, electronically stored information, written answers or testimony.

The California Privacy Protection Agency’s Enforcement Division describes contact that ranges from a call or an email to a tailored letter, an informal interview or an investigatory subpoena, and says it typically explores settlement before it starts litigation. The Agency says so in What to expect when enforcement comes knocking.

HIPAA investigations by the HHS Office for Civil Rights, state attorney general inquiries and securities regulators follow their own processes, which your counsel explains; for the record-keeping behind them, see HIPAA readiness and SEC disclosure readiness.

What we prepare

  • An intake route and an owner, so a letter sent to the wrong inbox reaches counsel the same day.
  • A record map: which systems hold which records, who administers them and how long each is kept, from data mapping and records management.
  • A hold procedure that stops routine deletion without stopping the business, with evidence handled as in preserving evidence after a breach.
  • A rehearsal, run as a tabletop on a realistic request.
Who does what when a regulator writes Two columns. Counsel speaks to the regulator and decides what to say. We prepare the records, the search and the evidence handling that counsel draws on. Your counsel We prepare Speaks to theregulator Records and wherethey are Decides what to say Search and holds
We do not represent clients before regulators.

How the work is bounded

The scope is agreed in writing before work starts, and the engagement is quoted in writing with it.

SecHB does not issue certifications, attestations or audit opinions: those come from accredited certification bodies, CPA firms and QSAs. The work here is what an organization does to be ready for them.

Nothing here is legal advice. Where a question turns on the law, the work is done alongside the client’s counsel, not instead of them.

Questions we are asked

What does inquiry preparation cover?

Preparing for a regulator inquiry is making sure that, when a letter or a demand arrives, the organization can find who owns it, what it asks for and which records answer it, within the time it gives.

Do you represent us before the regulator?

We do not represent you before a regulator and we do not give legal advice; your counsel handles the regulator, and we prepare the systems, records and people they will draw on.

What is an FTC civil investigative demand?

A civil investigative demand from the US Federal Trade Commission is a legally enforceable demand, and the FTC says recipients should respond promptly and fully and meet and confer with its staff about scope and deadlines.

How fast does the FTC expect a first conversation?

Under the FTC’s rules a recipient must meet and confer with Commission staff within 14 days after receiving the process or before the deadline for filing a petition to quash, whichever is first.

What does California’s privacy agency do?

The California Privacy Protection Agency’s Enforcement Division describes contact that ranges from a call or an email to a tailored letter, an informal interview or an investigatory subpoena, and says it typically explores settlement before it starts litigation.

Tell us what a letter would find

Say which regulators could write to you and where your records are. The reply says what a scope would cover. Read more: responding to an FTC civil investigative demand; the United States page.

Discuss a scope