Four business days under SEC Item 1.05: what the decision process looks like
Most of the time on the clock is not spent writing the filing. It is spent finding out who is allowed to say the incident is material, and what they need to see first.
Key points
- The four business days run from the company’s determination that the incident is material, not from discovery, and the determination is the thing a regulator will ask to see.
- A May 2024 staff statement says Item 1.05 is for incidents the company has determined to be material, and that a company that later finds an incident material files within four business days of that later determination.
- A workable process names who convenes the decision, what facts they are given, who decides, and where the decision and its date are recorded.
- The evidence log is the running record of what was known at each point, because the date of the determination is only as credible as the record behind it.
As of November 2026 these are the points in the SEC sources linked below. The rules and staff views can change, and your counsel confirms the current text.
What the SEC says
The SEC’s press release announcing the rules says an Item 1.05 Form 8-K is generally due four business days after the company determines the incident is material. The compliance guide adds that the Attorney General may authorize a delay where disclosure would pose a substantial risk to national security or public safety.
A May 2024 staff statement says Item 1.05 is for incidents the company has determined to be material, and that a company that later finds an incident material files within four business days of that later determination. The statement, by the Director of the Division of Corporation Finance, is on sec.gov. It is staff guidance, not a rule.
The process that produces a determination
A workable process names who convenes the decision, what facts they are given, who decides, and where the decision and its date are recorded. Nothing in the rule prescribes the steps; what follows is the working method we use to help companies prepare, and it is for your counsel to adopt or change.
- Escalation. A defined threshold at which the incident team tells the people who decide, with a one-page summary of what is known and not known.
- The deciders. Named in advance, with deputies, usually the disclosure committee and counsel.
- The facts they need. What systems, what data, what the business impact is so far, what is still being investigated.
- The decision. Material, not material, or not yet determined, with the reasons and the time, signed by the decider.
- The re-check. A scheduled point to decide again as facts change.
The evidence log
The evidence log is the running record of what was known at each point, because the date of the determination is only as credible as the record behind it. It records the facts as known at each hour, who learned them and when, and the questions still open. Kept from the first hour, it is also what the investigation and the regulators will want; see preserving evidence after a breach and the first 24 hours.
How the work is bounded
The scope is agreed in writing before work starts, and the engagement is quoted in writing with it.
SecHB does not issue certifications, attestations or audit opinions: those come from accredited certification bodies, CPA firms and QSAs. The work here is what an organization does to be ready for them.
Nothing here is legal advice. Where a question turns on the law, the work is done alongside the client’s counsel, not instead of them.
Questions we are asked
When does the four-business-day clock start?
The four business days run from the company’s determination that the incident is material, not from discovery, and the determination is the thing a regulator will ask to see.
What did the SEC staff say in 2024?
A May 2024 staff statement says Item 1.05 is for incidents the company has determined to be material, and that a company that later finds an incident material files within four business days of that later determination.
What should a decision process contain?
A workable process names who convenes the decision, what facts they are given, who decides, and where the decision and its date are recorded.
Why keep an evidence log?
The evidence log is the running record of what was known at each point, because the date of the determination is only as credible as the record behind it.
Build the path before it is needed
The service is SEC cybersecurity disclosure readiness. Tell us who would decide today and what they would see.